top of page
Search

The Competence Trap: Why Being Good at Your Job Keeps You in the Wrong One

Writer: Julian Gilbey
Julian Gilbey
24 minutes ago
5 min read

Meta description: Being good at your job can keep you in a role that no longer fits. Learn why competence gets rewarded with more of itself, and how to notice what you want next.

Observation

Someone asks you to lead the same piece of work again. You did it well last time. People trusted you to keep things steady, so now it feels natural to ask you again.

There’s a small sinking feeling when the request lands. Then you hear yourself say yes.

You know how to get started. You know who needs to be involved, where the snags are likely to be, and how to keep the work moving. In the meeting, you’re the calm, competent presence. You take the notes, spot the gap, answer the question.

And some part of you is elsewhere.

It can be hard to explain that feeling. The work is familiar. You’re good at it. People value what you bring. Yet when you look at the next few months, you see more of the same and feel your appetite go.

Reflection

Movement one: Notice what you choose, and what you get asked to do

Competence gets rewarded with more of itself. You handle a difficult project, so another one comes your way. You steady a team through a change, so you become the person everyone turns to when the next change arrives.

That recognition can feel good. It may bring more trust, responsibility and praise. It can also quietly fill your days with the things you know how to do, while leaving less room for the things that matter to you.

Being needed feels close to meaning. It can be easy to stop asking whether you want the work, especially when people are pleased with you for doing it. Praise confirms the decision to stay, even if the decision was made years ago and never properly looked at again.

One distinction worth noticing is the difference between work you volunteer for and work people routinely hand to you. You may willingly take on certain tasks because they interest you, stretch you or give you a sense of contribution. Others may land with you because you’re dependable and there’s little risk you’ll let them fall.

Both can look like success in a diary. They don’t feel the same from the inside.

If you’re among the high-achievers who feel stuck, this can be a particularly confusing place to find yourself. Your record gives you plenty of reasons to carry on. Your response to the work may be telling you something else.

Movement two: Take the cost of reliability seriously

There is a quiet cost to always being the reliable one. It shows up in time, certainly. It also shows up in your appetite for the work, and in the parts of yourself you’ve stopped practising.

Maybe you used to enjoy getting to grips with an unfamiliar problem. Now you spend most of the week making a familiar process run smoothly. Perhaps you once had ideas about a different kind of work, but you haven’t given them much room. The same request comes round again and you feel that short flash of irritation before you swallow it and get on with things.

There can be a sting in watching someone with less experience take on a piece of work that stirs you. They may be learning as they go. You could probably do it better. Still, you feel something when you see them have a go.

That feeling is worth paying attention to.

Skill without appetite can leave you doing a good job while feeling increasingly flat. You might put in the hours, deliver what’s needed and find yourself short-tempered at home after a day of performing competence. When this keeps going, chronic stress or burnout may be part of the picture. Either way, losing your appetite for work deserves attention before you explain it away as laziness or ingratitude.

In a coaching conversation, a capable person described being relied on to untangle difficult work. They had become so good at stepping in that nobody looked beyond that role. As we talked, it became clear that the strength they were proud of had also become a kind of enclosure. They weren’t ready to make a dramatic move. They were ready to have an honest conversation about what else they wanted to contribute.

That is often where a different kind of information starts to appear. In my work as a personal development coach, I see how easily people can mistake being useful for being in the right place.

Julian Gilbey at his desk in his home study, reflecting beside an open notebook

Movement three: Test the thought before you turn it into a life decision

You don’t need to hand in your notice to take your own dissatisfaction seriously. A decision about your career can begin with something smaller and more informative.

You might have a conversation about the shape of your role. You could ask for an afternoon to work on something you’ve set aside. Or, when the next obvious yes arrives, you might take a moment and give a considered no.

The point is to see what you learn. Does making space for different work bring some energy back? Does a conversation reveal that your role can change, or that the limits are firmer than you thought? Does saying no feel uncomfortable because you’re letting someone down, or because you’ve built an identity around always saying yes?

A small test won’t settle every question. It can give you a clearer view than another month of turning the same thoughts over in your head.

This is part of the work of a career transition: making sense of what no longer fits, and finding enough information to consider what might. It needn’t start with a complete plan.

The familiar question, “How to find purpose in life?”, can make it sound as though there is one grand answer waiting to be uncovered. Often the more useful clues are closer to hand. What kind of work still has your attention? What do you miss doing? When are you most present in your working day?

Question

Skilled and finished can both be true.

You may be very good at a job and have reached the point where you no longer want to spend your days doing it. Your competence tells you something real about your ability. It cannot decide the direction of your life for you.

That can be uncomfortable to accept, particularly when your reputation is tied to being the person who gets things done. You may worry that wanting different work means you’re being ungrateful, or that you’ll lose the respect you’ve built. You may have no clear picture of what comes next yet.

You can take that uncertainty seriously without treating it as a command to stay. The first part of The Next Chapter is listening for the signal in the middle of the ordinary day: the sinking feeling, the irritation, the flatness when the familiar work appears again.

Scorecard

If you’ve been asking yourself whether this is a passing frustration or a deeper career question, the Next Chapter Scorecard offers a way to look at what the current situation is costing you in your work, energy and relationships.

As you consider what it brings up, which part of your ability are you still choosing to use, and which part has simply become expected of you?

 
 
 

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page